S1E9 – Stenosis, Fear, and Facts: Navigating Spine Surgery with Dr. Allan Levi

Dr. Levi breaks down what stenosis actually is, why imaging findings so often don't match a patient's symptoms, and why some people walk around with "severe" degenerative changes on MRI and no pain at all. Together they trace the full continuum of care, from physical therapy and diagnostic epidural injections to the decision points around laminectomy versus fusion, and what recovery really looks like at each stage. It's a candid, myth-busting conversation for anyone facing a stenosis diagnosis or supporting a patient through one.

Listen on:

Listen on:

For anyone who’s ever been told their spine is “degenerating” or that they’re a millimeter from paralysis, the fear can feel as debilitating as the condition itself. In this episode, Dr. Brent sits down with his own neurosurgeon, Dr. Allan Levi — Chairman of Neurological Surgery at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine and Chief of Neurosurgery at Jackson Memorial Hospital — for a full-disclosure conversation about lumbar spinal stenosis, one year after Dr. Levi performed the surgery that gave Dr. Brent his leg back.

Dr. Levi breaks down what stenosis actually is, why imaging findings so often don’t match a patient’s symptoms, and why some people walk around with “severe” degenerative changes on MRI and no pain at all. Together they trace the full continuum of care, from physical therapy and diagnostic epidural injections to the decision points around laminectomy versus fusion, and what recovery really looks like at each stage. It’s a candid, myth-busting conversation for anyone facing a stenosis diagnosis or supporting a patient through one.

IN THIS EPISODE:

  • What lumbar spinal stenosis is and how degenerative versus congenital stenosis differ
  • Why MRI findings alone don’t tell the whole story, and how symptoms guide treatment
  • The role of epidural injections as both a diagnostic and therapeutic tool
  • How surgeons decide between a laminectomy and a spinal fusion
  • What recovery timelines and movement restrictions look like after each procedure
  • Why waiting too long for surgery can lead to worse outcomes — and why urgency isn’t always warranted
  • How to find the right spine specialist and know when a second opinion is worth seeking

RESOURCES MENTIONED:

  • University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, Department of Neurological Surgery
  • Jackson Memorial Hospital

DEFINITIONS:

  • Lumbar spinal stenosis — Narrowing of the spinal canal in the lower back, usually from a combination of enlarged facet joints and bulging discs, which can compress the nerve roots.
  • Neurogenic claudication — The pattern of back, buttock, and leg pain triggered by walking or standing and relieved by sitting, caused by nerve compression from stenosis.
  • Spondylolisthesis — A condition where one vertebra slides forward relative to the one below it; often described by patients as a “slip.”
  • Laminectomy — A surgical procedure that removes the lamina (back part of the vertebra) to create more space for compressed nerve roots, without fusing the spine.
  • Spinal fusion — A surgical procedure that joins two or more vertebrae together with bone growth and hardware, typically used when the spine is unstable.

SOURCES & CITATIONS:

  • Machado GC, Ferreira PH, Yoo RIJ, Harris IA, Pinheiro MB, Koes BW, van Tulder MW, Rzewuska M, Maher CG, Ferreira ML. Surgical options for lumbar spinal stenosis. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2016;11:CD012421. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD012421.
  • Machado GC, Ferreira PH, Harris IA, Pinheiro MB, Koes BW, van Tulder M, Rzewuska M, Maher CG, Ferreira ML. Effectiveness of Surgery for Lumbar Spinal Stenosis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. PLoS ONE. 2015;10(3):e0122800. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0122800.

Use the code DRBRENT to save 10% off any Polestar Pilates Teacher Trainings sold on polestarpilates.com. Applies only to Pay in Full.

00:00 — Cold Open

Dr. Brent frames the episode’s core question: what spinal stenosis really means, when surgery is necessary, and what recovery actually looks like.

03:45 — Welcome and Full Disclosure

Dr. Brent welcomes Dr. Allan Levi and publicly thanks him for the surgery that restored his leg one year earlier.

05:03 — Dr. Levi’s Background

Dr. Levi introduces his role as Chair of Neurosurgery at the University of Miami and his experience treating thousands of stenosis patients.

07:16 — Defining Spinal Stenosis

Dr. Levi explains the pathophysiology of lumbar stenosis, including facet joint enlargement and disc bulging that compress the spinal canal.

07:40 — Congenital vs. Degenerative Stenosis

Dr. Levi distinguishes stenosis caused by wear and tear from stenosis in people born with naturally smaller spinal canals.

08:14 — Imaging Doesn’t Always Match Symptoms

Dr. Brent and Dr. Levi discuss how degenerative changes are extremely common on MRI even in people with no back pain at all.

09:55 — Dr. Brent’s Own Case

Dr. Brent walks through his own confusing symptoms across his knee, foot, ankle, and hip before his stenosis diagnosis came into focus.

10:15 — The Diagnostic Epidural

Dr. Brent describes how an epidural injection helped pinpoint which spinal level was actually causing his symptoms.

11:53 — Stability and Individual Variation

Dr. Levi notes that every patient’s case is different, with some having instability associated with their stenosis.

12:47 — Neurogenic Claudication Explained

Dr. Levi defines the classic symptom pattern of leg and back pain that worsens with walking.

13:36 — Bowel and Bladder Symptoms as a Late Warning Sign

Dr. Levi warns that bowel or bladder changes are a late-stage finding that shouldn’t be the first thing patients wait for.

14:57 — The Role of Epidural Injections

Dr. Levi explains how injections work, how often they can safely be used, and their diagnostic value.

16:06 — Risks and Limits of Repeated Injections

Dr. Levi cautions against excessive injections, which can complicate future surgery.

18:31 — Stability vs. Instability

Dr. Brent asks Dr. Levi to walk through how he determines whether a patient’s spine is stable or unstable.

19:40 — What a Laminectomy Involves

Dr. Levi describes the standard decompression procedure and how it creates more room for compressed nerve roots.

21:16 — When Fusion Becomes Necessary

Dr. Levi explains how spondylolisthesis (vertebral slip) often requires fusion alongside decompression.

23:13 — The 2018 Meta-Analysis on Surgical Outcomes

Dr. Brent references a large meta-analysis finding no significant long-term difference between traditional laminectomy and newer surgical techniques.

23:51 — The Hype Around New Procedures

Dr. Brent raises concerns about aggressive marketing of newer surgical options like lumbar artificial discs.

24:36 — Cervical Artificial Disc Data

Dr. Levi shares his firsthand experience running early artificial disc trials and the resulting 10-year outcome data.

25:41 — Lumbar Artificial Disc Candidacy

Dr. Levi outlines who is actually a good candidate for lumbar artificial disc replacement.

26:55 — A Patient Success Story

Dr. Brent shares a case of a young dancer who recovered quickly after cervical artificial disc surgery.

27:36 — Preventing Adjacent Joint Syndrome

Dr. Brent describes movement strategies used in physical therapy to protect the spinal segments next to a fusion.

28:49 — Post-Surgical Movement Protocols

Dr. Brent introduces the topic of precautions and restrictions issued after laminectomy versus fusion.

29:57 — Laminectomy Recovery: The “No BLT” Rule

Dr. Levi explains the standard no-bending, no-lifting, no-twisting guidance for the first six weeks after a laminectomy.

30:38 — Returning to Normal Life

Dr. Levi describes the typical six-week timeline before patients resume a more normal routine.

31:52 — Fusion Recovery and Bracing

Dr. Levi explains the bracing process and roughly 12-month bone-healing timeline after a spinal fusion.

33:28 — Finding the Right Spine Specialist

Dr. Levi shares what patients should look for in a neurosurgeon or orthopedic spine surgeon, including specialization and experience.

34:56 — When to Get a Second Opinion

Dr. Levi advises seeking a second opinion, especially for uncommon conditions like deformity, tumors, or infection.

35:34 — Beware Surgical Fear Tactics

Dr. Levi cautions against surgeons who claim surgery is needed immediately to avoid paralysis.

36:00 — The Risk of Waiting Too Long

Dr. Levi and Dr. Brent discuss how delaying necessary surgery for years can lead to worse outcomes from chronic nerve compression.

36:41 — Neuroplastic Pain After Long Delays

Dr. Brent explains how waiting too long can create pain patterns disconnected from actual tissue damage.

37:11 — Closing Thoughts Dr. Levi and Dr. Brent close the conversation with final thanks and a reminder to live aligned.

Dr. Allan Levi

Dr. Allan Levi

MD, PhD, FAANS

Allan D. Levi, MD, PhD, FAANS is a tenured Professor and Chairman of the Department of Neurological Surgery at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine; Professor, Departments of Orthopedics and Rehabilitation Medicine; Chief of Neurosurgery, Jackson Memorial Hospital; and the Mary M and Sash A Spencer Endowed Chair in Neurological Surgery. Dr. Levi graduated from the University of Ottawa Medical School. He completed his residency at the University of Toronto, as well as a spine fellowship at the Barrow Neurological Institute in Phoenix, AZ. In addition, he received a PhD in neuroscience at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine. Dr. Levi has extensive experience as a spine and peripheral nerve neurosurgeon, including developing new surgical techniques using minimally invasive approaches. Dr. Levi’s research interests have been funded by the NIH and DOD and include cellular transplantation strategies after spinal cord and peripheral nerve injury. Some of Dr. Levi’s current clinical research trials involving the clinical development and characterization of the use of autologous human Schwann cells for peripheral nerve injuries with a lengthy gap as well as a multi-center trial in the use of hypothermia after acute SCI. Dr. Levi has been the Course Director of the AANS Goodman Oral Board Preparation Course for almost 20 years. He is also a member of the Senior Society of Neurosurgery and the American Academy of Neurosurgery.

Subscribe to Live Aligned with Dr. Brent

Get notified when new episodes are released and stay up to date with the latest insights on movement, rehabilitation, and Pilates education.

LEAVE A MESSAGE

Share yours thoughts, questions, or feedback width Dr. Brent.